Judith jarvis thomson: a defense of abortion i thomson's project thomson grants for the sake of argument the premise that a human embryo is a person she challenges the idea that one can argue effectively from this premise to the conclusion that all abortion is morally impermissible. A christian's view on abortion an abortion is the medical procedure of inducing expulsion of a human foetus to terminate a pregnancy doctors use the term abortion to mean any death of a baby in the womb of its mother and the expulsion from the body. Thomson's thought experiment has also been replied to by oxford philosopher john finnis in the rights and wrongs of abortion: a reply to judith thomson thomson in turn replied to finnis in her paper, rights and deaths, reprinted in her volume of essays, rights, restitution, and risk. Thomson argues this tact distracts from the primary concern of abortion, for even if one grants that a foetus is a person, one’s work is still ahead of them to argue against the permissibility of abortion (thomson: page 48. The argument of the legality, or more specifically the morality, of abortion is something that seems to polarize any group the argument weighs heavy on the opinion of one's moral responsibility and right to use of ones own body versus the right to life of a human being.
Thomson's defense is a classic example of blame the victim its influence continues, despite rebuttals by scholars on both sides of the abortion debate here are some of my reasons why her analogy fails. Free abortion research papers were donated by our members/visitors and are presented free of charge for informational use only the essay or term paper you are seeing on this page was not produced by our company and should not be considered a sample of our research/writing service. Judith jarvis thomson: a defense of abortion for example, it already has a face, arms and less, fingers and toes it has internal organs, and brain activity is detectable on the other hand, i think that the premise is false, that the fetus is not a person from the moment of conception let us call the view that abortion is. Thomson's view of abortion in the article a defense of abortion judith jarvis thomson argues that abortion is morally permissible even if the fetus is considered a person in this paper i will give a fairly detailed description of thomson main arguments for abortion.
- in this paper i will explain and examine judith jarvis thomson’s view on abortion as outlined in her essay “a defense of abortion” i will summarize her perspective on the issue, and will then criticize and support her arguments and the analogies she includes. In her influential essay “a defense of abortion, on thomson’s view, and most people agree, for example, thomson argues that abortion is always permissible in the case of rape because “in a case of pregnancy due to rape the mother has not. Later in her essay, she uses even more bizarre scenarios in an attempt to justify abortion, but so far thomson’s essay is not off to a very promising start  see also frank beckwith’s books politically correct death and defending life , as well as christopher kaczor’s the ethics of abortion.
A defense of abortion is a moral philosophy paper by judith jarvis thomson first published in 1971 granting for the sake of argument that the fetus has a right to life, thomson uses thought experiments to argue that the fetus's right to life does not trump the pregnant woman's right to control her own body and its life-support functions, and that induced abortion is therefore not morally. Rights, restitution, and risk: essays, in moral theory user review - not available - book verdict here are 13 of mit professor thomson's best essays on moral philosophy, which deal with some of the most timely and complex issues facing modern society. Thomson refers to the violinist example to be similar to an unwanted pregnancy related to a rape incident throughout thomson’s argument it’s explained to be an unjust killing to unplug the violinist, and as a result an abortion violates the right to life too in order to adequately criticize thomson’s view we must evaluate the.
The second thing that the example establishes is that for many opponents of abortion (all those who say it is ok to unplug oneself from the violinist) the right to life of the fetus plays only a small background role in their justification of abortion’s impermissibility of course, if the fetus did not have a right to life then abortion would. In thomson’s view, the death of the fetus is a necessary side-effect of abortion, but is not a legitimate goal of abortion were it possible to remove a fetus without killing it, then it must not be killed. Abortion essay procedure of abortion is known since ancient times the word abortion is came the latin abortus where “ab” means “amiss” and “oriri” means “likely to be born, arise”(1) along with infanticide it has existed in many societies, both primitive and advanced. Lucinda seongbae eng : persuasive essay on abortion prof fitzgerald a positive view on pro abortion abortion has been a controversy for many years and viewed in many different perspectives some individuals see it from a very positive point when this is being caused by the nature of the woman’s health, the age and others.
So within this essay we will asses what judith jarvis thomson’s (1978) ‘famous violinist scenario’ was supposed to show assessing whether the scenario is analogous to cases of (1) unwanted pregnancies, (2) abortion. In the next few lines i summarize, in the first place, j thomsom´s essay a defense of abortion, her thesis, arguments, and some of her examples i will then argue why thomsom´s thesis seems to me deeper and stronger than the other three essays that we have read in class on abortion. Abortion,”1 judith jarvis thomson offers what i will call the violinist example to show that merely having a right to life does not in and of itself give rise in the fetus to a right to use the mother’s body. Judith jarvis thomson’s essay, titled “a defense of abortion” illustrates what most would describe as a liberal view on abortion although thomson acknowledges the fetus as a human, she argues that this should not dictate a woman’s choice to abortion.
A regrettably inadequate defence of abortion this essay shall examine and critique judith jarvis thomson’s analogy of the sickly violinist, as it relates to the moral permissibility of abortion. The morality of abortion essay sample abortion is morally impermissible i agree with marquis that abortion is morally impermissible because it is a process that leads to loss of life. Judith jarvis thomson’s seminal piece is that abortion is permissible because the fetus has no right to be inside the woman 1 if the fetus has no right to be inside the woman, there is then a well-developed debate on whether abortion.