In favor of the existence of thought without language, neurologists present the case of a man with post-traumatic aphasia he had verbal performance of a child of four or five years, but was very above average for performance on nonverbal tests: it is a sign that thought and language are not totally linked. The title does not say, “does language control all thoughts” it just says thought so is the question asking whether we can think without using a language as the means of thought. However, while it appears that we can indeed think without language, it is also the case that there are certain kinds of thinking that are made possible by language. My seventh-grade english teacher exhorted us to study vocabulary with the following: we think in words the more words you know, the more thoughts you can have.
We are always thinking, but aside from basic information like pain we (or at least i believe so) think in our native language i understand (basicaly) how language was started, vague jab at christian babel story here but i don't understand how thinking was done before it. Language we speak determines thoughts we can have (so culture too) if you can't express it in english, you can't think about it - but then how new words/ideas why borrow words (déjà vu) if we didn't already have concept (but no language. The question “can we think without language” is a difficult one – one that requires even more questions from philosophers – how do we “know” anything (epistemology) at a basic level – yes we can think without language insofar as animals clearly can do it.
Noam chomksy speaks about this same topic - . Can we think without language many anthropologists, linguists, psychologists, biologists and other academics have attempted to tackle this question in recent decades. I think without words constantly it may be part of having a language processing disorder shapes the easiest way to move ideas around is to get rid of the words altogether, label them as a thing, and forget the words while using the thingwhen you get the things placed correctly, you can pull out the words you need. Before people had a language, how could they think greg matthews, london • post questions and answers below or email them to [email protected] include name, address and phone number.
Well, i think one of the things that we can do is to have early childhood education programs that will help children to have those kinds of experiences that we know are important for them. If we think using language, then new thoughts that do not already exist in the language may never be formulated if thinking is possible without language, then what is it and why do animals not. About the conditions under which we think best and trying to bring them about in this section i will delineate more precisely the scope of the distinctive type of reflection made availabl by the presence of language. Re: how do we think without language the difficulty associated with thinking without language is a reason to believe that the smartest animals, like apes and dophins, are actually closer to humans, intelligence wise, than they appear. I don't think one can exist without the other culture is the natural product of human society the rites and rituals and observances we enjoy bind us together, and give us our group identity, and lend meaning to our existence.
In other words, the influence of language isn't so much on what we can think about, or even what we do think about, but rather on how we break up reality into categories and label them and in this, our language and our thoughts are probably both greatly influenced by our culture. Since there is no evidence that any language forbids its speakers to think anything, we must look in an entirely different direction to discover how our mother tongue really does shape our. People communicate without using words during a normal day without even realising a common way to find out how someone is feeling is through body language for example if a person is jittery and. A variety of different authors, theories and fields purport influences between language and thought psychologists attempt to explain the emergence of thought and language in human evolution there are two bodies of thought forming around this debate.
Yes, because thoughts and out consience make up a part of what we are, and we would still exist as we do if language did not exist also, some animals, such as some fish and very small children can not use any language at all, but still think, and still exist. Language is the tool that our mind uses to build complex thoughts, without language it still can think but not nearly as efficiently and powerfully than with language permalink embed. Yes we can 1) people who cannot speak can still play games such as charades a person without language would also be able to play that game, which means that they would have the concept of what they’re acting out, and they could be able to think about what they are doing. Without language, we think like infants or animals—by instinct, habit, and primitive communication systems the absence of inner speech does not mean unhappiness, in fact, it may lead to profound joy.